The Countdown Timer Points Back

After weeks of hunting, the motorcycle trailer finally showed up on Marketplace, and it glowed. Something you’ve been hunting for weeks always glows a little when it finally shows up, like it knows you’ve been waiting and would prefer you didn’t think too hard about it.

I messaged the seller fast.

A day later I found a better one. Smaller. It already had a motorcycle chock installed (the exact piece I would have spent an afternoon in the garage swearing at to install myself). It fit me better in every way that counted, and I nearly never saw it, because the first one felt like now.

Urgency feels exactly the same whether it’s right or wrong.

The flight to our sales kickoff came with the same little rush. I booked it quickly and felt very organized about it, the way you do when you’ve crossed something off before anyone asked. Then I learned I needed to be there a day earlier to help with setup. So I got to do the whole thing twice, the second time with a lot less smugness.

Good ideas are the sneakiest version. A while back I had a campaign idea that lit me up like a pinball machine… people would talk about it, forward it, maybe even remember it. It was also pure awareness, and the goal the team had actually signed up for was pipeline. Revenue. It was a great idea built for a different scoreboard, and the excitement never once mentioned that.

So the feeling can’t be what decides.

It isn’t lying, exactly. It just doesn’t know anything. Urgency is a doorbell. It tells you someone is at the door. It has no opinion about whether you should open it, and it rings just as loud for the neighbor bringing back your drill as for the guy selling knives.

The one-star review is the hardest test, because that urgency shows up dressed as responsibility. Every hour it sits there unanswered feels like strangers are learning something about you. I did answer it. Just not right away. I let it breathe, went to my team, got the facts straight about what actually happened, and then wrote back. The reply I sent knew things the reply I wanted to send never would have.

Marketers should be the best in the world at this, and we might be the worst. We build the countdown timers. We write “only three left” and “ends at midnight” and put the little red dot on the icon. We know that feeling is a lever because we pull it for a living… and then it gets pointed back at us by a shiny idea, a perfect listing or an angry stranger, and we sprint like we’ve never seen the trick.

The answer isn’t to slow everything down. Some trailers really do sell in an hour. Some reviews really do need a same-day reply. The answer is to get a second opinion, because the feeling can’t give you one. A breath. A soundboard who isn’t lit up. A quick look at the goal you already wrote down, held next to the thing that’s yelling. Pipeline or awareness. The trailer I need or the trailer that happens to be here.

That comparison is boring, which is exactly why it works. Urgency hates boring. It can’t survive being set next to a spreadsheet.

The better trailer was a day away. The review response, too. The campaign idea that drove revenue, as well.

Most of the better things are. You just can’t see them from inside the hurry, because the hurry was built to make sure you don’t look.

Stay Positive & Find A Second Scoreboard

Garth Beyer
Latest posts by Garth Beyer (see all)

Share A Response